Peristaltic or Diaphragm Dosing Pump?
Peristaltic or diaphragm? The chemical and the site decide.
Both dose accurately. Which one suits you depends on what you dose and where the pump works. Choose your application below to see which, and why.
Choose by application
Press the one closest to yours.
Sodium hypochlorite (liquid chlorine)
Peristaltic It keeps dosing when the chlorine gives off gas.
- Liquid chlorine gives off gas all the time, more when it is warm or old. In a diaphragm pump the gas collects in the head and the pump runs but doses nothing (vapour lock).
- A peristaltic pump pushes gas and liquid alike, so it cannot vapour lock, and it has no check valves for chlorine scale to build up on.
Line pressure too high for a peristaltic pump? A multi-diaphragm pump built for gassing chemicals is the alternative.
Pools, spas and aquatic centres
By pool size Chosen by the flow the pool needs, and that comes from its size in litres.
- The bigger the pool, the more chlorine and acid it takes each hour, so the larger the pump.
- Small to mid-size pools: a peristaltic pump doses the chlorine without vapour lock and primes itself straight from the drum.
- Large pools and aquatic centres: a dual diaphragm or motor-driven pump gives the larger flow, smooth and steady.
- A diaphragm pump with pH or ORP control built in is a simple choice for acid, and for chlorine where the pump sits below the tank.
Start with the Pool Dosing Calculator: type the pool's litres and it works out the flow needed. The pumps below go from the smallest flow to the largest. Or tell us the pool's volume, and we will size the pump.
For this application we recommend looking at:
- Pool Dosing Calculator Start here: works out the flow from the pool's litres
- SEKO Kompact Up to 5 L/h. Solenoid diaphragm, pH or ORP control built in
- AQUA TEC series Up to 6 L/h. Peristaltic, for small pools and spas
- FLEXFLO® A1A Up to 15.8 L/h. Peristaltic, chlorine and acid, small to mid-size pools
- AQUA HC151+ pH-RX Up to 20 L/h. Solenoid diaphragm, pH or ORP control built in
- CHEM-FEED® MD1 Up to 26 L/h. Dual diaphragm, for large pools
- CHEM-FEED® C-600P Up to 81 L/h. Motor-driven diaphragm made for pools, for the largest
Polymer (flocculant, coagulant aid)
Peristaltic Gentle on the polymer, and happy with thick polymer.
- Polymer works through its long molecular chains. The fast strokes and narrow valves of a diaphragm pump can tear them (shear), so more polymer is needed for the same result.
- A peristaltic pump squeezes the tube gently, with no valves for the polymer to pass through.
Polymer does not conduct electricity: if the pump has tube leak detection, check that it senses polymer.
For this application we recommend looking at:
Thick (viscous) chemicals
Peristaltic A peristaltic pump takes liquids as thick as honey.
- Thick liquid is slow to fill a diaphragm pump's head and slow to let its check valves close, so the dose falls short.
- A peristaltic pump has no valves: the roller pushes the liquid along whatever its thickness.
Thick chemicals need a larger suction line and a pump running slower. Tell us the chemical, and we will size the pump and the tube.
For this application we recommend looking at:
Slurries and solids (lime, powdered carbon)
Peristaltic Solids pass through the tube; there are no valves to clog.
- In a diaphragm pump, particles settle on the check valves and stop them closing, so the pump loses accuracy or stops dosing.
- In a peristaltic pump the slurry touches only the inside of the tube, and the roller pushes the solids through.
For this application we recommend looking at:
Hydrogen peroxide
Peristaltic Peroxide gives off gas, and a peristaltic pump cannot vapour lock.
- Hydrogen peroxide slowly breaks down into water and oxygen, and the bubbles can stop a diaphragm pump.
- A peristaltic pump pushes the bubbles through with the liquid.
Choose a tube rated for the strength you dose.
For this application we recommend looking at:
Peracetic acid
Multi-diaphragm A pump made for gassing chemicals, in materials that resist it.
- Peracetic acid gives off gas, which can stop a standard diaphragm pump.
- A multi-diaphragm pump built for gassing chemicals doses it without vapour lock. Strong peracetic acid attacks many peristaltic tubes, so a peristaltic pump suits only weaker solutions, with a tube rated for them.
Tell us the strength you dose, and we will confirm the pump and its materials.
For this application we recommend looking at:
Acid for pH control (hydrochloric, sulphuric)
Either works Both work: choose by the acid's strength and the line pressure.
- Clean liquids that do not give off gas are what diaphragm pumps do best, at the lowest cost.
- A peristaltic pump suits them too, with a tube rated for the acid. Concentrated acid into a higher-pressure line is a job for a diaphragm pump.
Caustic soda (sodium hydroxide)
Either works Both work, with the right tube or diaphragm.
- Caustic soda does not give off gas, so either pump doses it well.
- Choose the tube, or the diaphragm and valves, in a material rated for caustic.
50% caustic soda starts to crystallise below about 12 °C. Crystals can hold a check valve open, so in a cold plant room use a weaker solution or keep the tank and lines warm.
Coagulants (ferric chloride, alum)
Either works Both work; choose by flow, pressure and upkeep.
- Ferric chloride and alum are clean liquids that do not give off gas.
- For large, steady flows into low-pressure lines, a peristaltic pump gives smooth dosing over a wide range; for higher pressures, a diaphragm pump.
Cooling towers and boilers (inhibitors, dispersants)
Diaphragm Small, steady doses into a pressurised line, at low cost.
- These treatment chemicals are clean and do not give off gas: the work diaphragm pumps do best.
- Diaphragm pumps hold higher pressure, and on clean chemicals the diaphragm and valves last a long time, with no tube to change.
Dosing liquid chlorine as the biocide? It gives off gas: see Sodium hypochlorite.
For this application we recommend looking at:
High-pressure lines (above about 7 bar)
Diaphragm Diaphragm pumps go higher.
- Most peristaltic dosing pumps go up to about 7 or 8 bar, and pressure wears the tube more than anything else.
- Diaphragm dosing pumps commonly reach 10 bar and more.
A diaphragm pump gives less as the pressure rises; a peristaltic pump gives the same at any pressure within its rating. Check the flow at your line pressure: the pump selector does this for you.
For this application we recommend looking at:
Remote sites, or the pump above the tank
Peristaltic It primes itself and holds its prime, with no one there.
- It cannot vapour lock or lose prime, so it keeps dosing between visits, and running the tank dry does it no harm.
- It lifts several metres straight from a bulk tank, so the tank need not sit above the pump. A tube change takes a few minutes and no tools, on the next visit.
Plan tube changes by running hours, and choose a pump with tube leak detection to stop it and raise an alarm if a tube splits.
For this application we recommend looking at:
How each pump works
The difference is in how the chemical is moved. The chemical is in green: see how smoothly each pump moves it.
Peristaltic
- Rollers turn and squeeze a flexible tube against the pump head.
- Each squeeze pushes the chemical in the tube along to the outlet.
- Behind the roller the tube springs back open and draws in more chemical.
- The chemical touches only the inside of the tube: no valves, no seals.
Diaphragm
- A solenoid or a motor moves a flexible diaphragm back and forth.
- Moving back, it draws chemical in through the suction check valve.
- Moving forward, it pushes the chemical out through the discharge check valve.
- The check valves let the chemical go one way only, one stroke at a time.
Dual diaphragm
- One motor drives two diaphragms, one on each side.
- While one draws chemical in, the other pushes it out, so the flow is nearly continuous.
- Each side has its own check valves, and both feed the one line.
- Many are built to dose gassing chemicals such as sodium hypochlorite without vapour lock.
Peristaltic or diaphragm: an honest comparison
Both pump types dose accurately: each is stronger at different things. ✓ Green marks the stronger of the two on each point.
| Peristaltic | Diaphragm | Why it matters for your application | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chemicals that give off gas | Keeps dosing: the gas passes through with the liquid. | Gas can collect in the head and stop the dose (vapour lock). Multi-diaphragm and degassing pumps are built to cope. | Liquid chlorine, hydrogen peroxide, peracetic acid. A pump that stops overnight leaves a pool or a supply untreated. |
| Thick chemicals | Takes liquids as thick as honey. | Best with thin liquids: thick ones fill the head slowly and the dose falls short. | Polymer, some coagulants and concentrated products. |
| Polymer | A gentle squeeze and no valves: the polymer's chains stay whole. | Fast strokes and narrow valves can tear (shear) the chains. | Torn polymer works less well, so more is used for the same result. |
| Solids and slurries | Pass through the tube. | Particles settle on the check valves and stop them closing. | Lime, powdered carbon, and chemicals that crystallise. |
| Line pressure | Lower: usually up to about 7 or 8 bar, and pressure shortens the tube's life. | Higher: commonly 10 bar and more. | Boilers, high-pressure mains and long injection lines. |
| Flow as the pressure changes | Stays the same. | Falls as the pressure rises: set the pump at the working pressure. | Lines whose pressure changes through the day. |
| Smooth flow | Nearly continuous. | In pulses, one per stroke; dual and multi-diaphragm pumps are smoother. | Even mixing in small lines, and steady readings at a controller's probe. |
| Suction and priming | Primes itself and lifts several metres; running dry does it no harm. | Lifts less, and can lose prime when the tank runs dry. Best fed from above. | A pump above the tank, and remote or unmanned sites. |
| Accuracy | Accurate; the dose falls slowly as the tube wears, so check it from time to time. | Accurate on clean chemicals at a steady pressure. | Either, sized well and calibrated on site. |
| Upkeep | The tube wears with every turn and is changed regularly: a few minutes, no tools. | On clean chemicals the diaphragm and valves last a long time; clean the valves, and fit a service kit at the maker's interval, often yearly. | For clean chemicals, a diaphragm pump needs the least attention. |
| When it wears out | A worn tube splits and leaks inside the pump head: choose a pump with tube leak detection. | Dirty or worn valves usually stop the dose, often without a sign. | Know how the pump will fail, and check it on the right schedule. |
| Cost | Usually more to buy, and tubes are a regular cost. | Usually less to buy, and less to run on clean chemicals. | For clean chemicals at higher pressure, a diaphragm pump is the economical choice. |
In short: a peristaltic pump for difficult chemicals (gassing, thick, polymer, slurries) and difficult sites (the pump above the tank, no one there). A diaphragm pump for clean chemicals, higher pressure and the lowest cost.
Getting the most from each
Peristaltic
- Size the pump to run slowly. Our rule of thumb: a pump that gives your normal dose at no more than about a third of its top speed (35%). The tube lasts longer, and there is room to dose more when needed.
- Keep the line pressure as low as the job allows: pressure wears the tube more than anything else.
- Choose the tube for the chemical, and change it by running hours, before it wears through.
Diaphragm
- Keep the suction line short, or put the pump below the tank so the chemical flows into it.
- Clean the check valves, and fit the service kit at the maker’s interval.
- Choose the diaphragm, valves and seals in materials rated for the chemical.
Still not sure which suits you?
Tell us the chemical, how much you dose and the line pressure, and we will recommend the pump. Or call 1300 585 820.